Real County Post

  • About Us
    • Hill Country Post
      • Newsletter
      • Our Lead Editor
      • Editors
      • Heroes
        • Hero Stories
        • Wall of Remembrance
    • Mission Transition
      • Related Posts
      • Website
    • Contact Us
  • News
    • Community
    • Finance
    • Food & Health
    • Lifestyle
    • Obituaries
    • Sports
  • Counties
    • Share a Local Story
      • Community Events
      • Community History
    • Bandera
      • Related Stories
      • Officials & Public Places
      • Local Churches
      • Parks
      • Did You Know …
    • Blanco
      • Related Stories
      • Officials & Public Places
      • Local Churches
      • Parks
      • Did You Know …
    • Edwards
      • Related Stories
      • Officials & Public Places
      • Local Churches
      • Parks
      • Did You Know …
    • Frio
      • Related Stories
      • Officials & Public Places
      • Local Churches
      • Parks
      • Did You Know …
    • Gillespie
      • Related Stories
      • Officials & Public Places
      • Local Churches
      • Parks
      • Did You Know …
    • Kendall
      • Related Stories
      • Officials & Public Places
      • Local Churches
      • Parks
      • Did You Know …
    • Kerr
      • Related Stories
      • Officials & Public Places
      • Local Churches
      • Parks
      • Did You Know …
    • Medina
      • Related Stories
      • Officials & Public Places
      • Local Churches
      • Parks
      • Did You Know …
    • Real
      • Related Stories
      • Officials & Public Places
      • Local Churches
      • Parks
      • Did You Know …
    • Uvalde
      • Related Stories
      • Officials & Public Places
      • Local Churches
      • Parks
      • Did You Know …
  • Shop
    • Cart 🛒
    • Checkout ⇒
  • Advertise Here
    • Submit Your Ad
    • Featured Block Ads
    • Free Business Ads
      • Agricultural
      • Business Services
      • Construction Services
      • Healthcare Providers
      • Hunting & Fishing
      • Lodging & Recreational
      • Personal Care
      • Real Estate
      • Restaurants & Markets
      • Retail & Miscellaneous
  • Listings
  • Account

Here’s what U.S. Supreme Court justices had to say about Texas’ abortion law

BY REESE OXNER at The Texas Tribune, NOV. 1, 2021

Sign up for The Brief, our daily newsletter that keeps readers up to speed on the most essential Texas news.

The U.S. Supreme Court took up Texas’ restrictive new abortion law Monday, two months after it went into effect.

The justices questioned attorneys representing abortion providers, Texas and the federal government for three hours, providing hints into how the high court might eventually rule in the two challenges against Senate Bill 8.

The Supreme Court has published transcripts for the oral arguments made by abortion providers and the U.S. Department of Justice. Here is a selection of some of the most notable quotes from Monday’s proceedings:

Supremacy of federal law

“Texas designed SB 8 to thwart the supremacy of federal law in open defiance of our constitutional structure. States are free to ask this court to reconsider its constitutional precedents, but they are not free to place themselves above this court, nullify the court’s decisions in their borders and block the judicial review necessary to vindicate federal rights.”

— U.S. solicitor general Elizabeth Prelogar in her opening remarks

“Procedural morass” 

“Tell me if I’m wrong on this, that just the procedural morass we’ve got ourselves into with this extremely unusual law is that we would really be telling the Fifth Circuit, again, if your position prevailed, that the district court had to be allowed to continue with its preliminary injunction ruling.”

— Justice Elena Kagan, commenting to the counsel for abortion providers on the muddy situation and how relief would mean undoing lower court orders

A hypothetical about AR-15s

“Say everyone who sells an AR-15 is liable for a million dollars to any citizen … Would that kind of law be exempt from pre-enforcement review in federal court?”

— Justice Brett Kavanaugh, questioning Texas Solicitor General Judd Stone on his perceived limits of the Texas abortion law’s mechanism. (Stone responded yes.)

“The point of a right”

“Isn’t the point of a right that you don’t have to ask Congress? Isn’t the point of a right that it doesn’t really matter what Congress thinks or what the majority of the American people think as to that right?”

— Kagan, in response to Texas’ argument that only Congress, not courts, has the authority to overturn Texas’ law because of how it is enforced

State laws and constitutional rights 

“The entire point of this law, its purpose and its effect, is to find the chink in the armor of Ex parte Young … And the fact that after all these many years, some geniuses came up with a way to evade the commands of that decision, as well as the command that the even broader principle that states are not to nullify federal constitutional rights, and to say, ‘oh, we’ve never seen this before, so we can’t do anything about it’ — I guess I just don’t understand the argument.”

— Kagan, pointing out her questions about how the creators of SB 8 employed Ex parte Young, a 1908 Supreme Court case allowing exceptions to a state’s sovereign immunity in some cases

“A loophole”

“There’s a loophole that’s been exploited here or used here, which is the private suits are enforced by state court clerks or judges. So the question becomes, should we extend the principle of Ex parte Young to, in essence, close that loophole?”

— Kavanaugh, also pointing to the “loophole” that allows Texas’ law to skirt judicial review

“Novel law”

“I recognize that this seems like a novel case and that’s because it’s a novel law.”

— Prelogar, commenting on the strangeness of the U.S. directly suing the state of Texas

In the cosmos

“General, are you aware of a precedent that permits an injunction against all persons in the country or the world, the cosmos, who bring suit?”

— Justice Neil Gorsuch to Prelogar. (Her answer: “No, Justice Gorsuch. Our injunction doesn’t do that either.”)

“Open for business”

“I mean, that was something that until this law came along no state dreamed of doing. And, essentially, we would be like, you know, we’re open for business — you’re open for business. There’s nothing the Supreme Court can do about it. Guns, same-sex marriage, religious rights, whatever you don’t like, go ahead.”

— Kagan, on what might happen if the court allows states to enforce laws in the way Texas set up its abortion restrictions

Defining injury 

“Well, the injury would be akin to the one suffered in a tort of outrage, where a person witnesses something they essentially find to be so extreme and outrageous it causes them extreme moral or — or otherwise psychological harm.”

— Texas solicitor general Judd Stone, on the state’s argument that private citizens can demonstrate injury in lawsuits filed under Texas’ law

Nov 1, 2021Hill Country Post

See the original article: https://feeds.texastribune.org/link/16799/14846918/supreme-court-texas-abortion-quotes

1 year ago Featured, Hill Country Newsabortion, courts, Texas Government, Texas Policy, Texas Politics, U.S. Supreme Court20
Hill Country Post
Democratic state Reps. Claudia Ordaz Perez and Art Fierro will vie for the same El Paso House seat due to redistrictingFights over the Alamo persist as George P. Bush seeks higher office

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

 About Us 

A centralized state of the arts source of information for people who live, work or visit the Texas Hill Country. See About Us for more details.

 Recent News 
  • Dershowitz: Trump indictment supercharges 2024 support March 24, 2023
  • West Texas A&M University students file free speech lawsuit after president cancels campus drag show March 24, 2023
  • ‘Project Texas’ could be the solution to prevent the U.S. ban of TikTok March 24, 2023
  • New Texas bill would ban ‘Lonesome Dove’ over ‘explicit’ content March 24, 2023
 Contact Us 

Share your Hill Country stories with us. We gladly welcome community input and suggestions for articles on our website.

Phone: (210) 568-1568

Email: editor@hillcountrypost.org

Follow Us on Social Media
Follow Us on FacebookFollow Us on TwitterFollow Us on InstagramFollow Us on Gab
Visitors:
2019 - 2021 © Hill Country Post | A Community-Based Initiative of the Mission Transition Foundation A 501(c)(3) Public Non-profit | Terms & Conditions | Powered by Fidelity Partners Website Designs

Make a pit stop at our Hill Country Community Shop 🛍️ Dismiss